Overridden fail-safe system a possible cause of Katz plane crash

By Joe Brandt

The plane crash that killed Temple trustee and Philadelphia Inquirer owner Lewis Katz on May 31 may have been caused by an override of the jet’s fail-safe system, according to the Inquirer.

The Inquirer obtained a copy of a letter dated Aug. 18 which Gulfstream Aerospace Corp. sent to pilots and owners of its jets.

The letter cautioned that Gulfstream fail-safe systems, which normally limit the plane to taxi speed while the gust lock is engaged, can be overridden if “proper [tail flap] unlock procedures are not followed.”

The movable tail and wing flaps are a crucial part of a plane’s takeoff, providing lift, but many planes have gust-lock systems to hold the flaps in place and protect them from potentially damaging wind while the plane is parked.

In June, investigators from the National Transportation Safety Board found through analysis of the  flight data recorder in Katz’s plane that no pre-flight control check was performed and that “[tail and wing flap] position during the taxi and takeoff was consistent with its position if the gust lock was engaged,” according to an NTSB report.

The Inquirer article, posted online August 20, quoted from Massachusetts Institute of Technology aeronautics and astronautics professor John Hansman Jr.

Hansman said the pilots should have turned off the gust-lock and then started the engines, but instead started the engines before disengaging the lock, overriding the fail-safe system and allowing the plane to reach greater speeds. The plane reached about 190 mph before it crashed.

Additionally, a professional pilot of Gulfstream jets, Steven M. Janos, told the Inquirer: “[m]y understanding is that if you start the engine, you will not be able to release the gust lock.”

Katz’s plane crashed and burst into flames at Hanscom Field near Boston, Mass. after he attended a fundraising event at the house of author and historian Doris Kearns Goodwin.

Four days earlier, he had won control of the Inquirer, the Philadelphia Daily News, and philly.com with fellow Temple trustee and business partner H.F. “Gerry” Lenfest.

The three passengers and three crew members on board died in the crash, along with Katz.

Joe Brandt can be reached at jbrandt@temple.edu or on Twitter @JBrandt_TU.

CST adviser sues Temple for discrimination

An adviser from the College of Science and Technology filed a federal lawsuit against Temple yesterday, the Philadelphia Daily News reported. He says he was denied a promotion on the basis of his race.

Kenneth Ruff, who is African American, advises CST students with last names N through O. He also advises for TUTeach, a program for preparing high school math and science teachers.

According to the Daily News, Ruff said in the suit that he was the only African American among five advisers when the advising program was reorganized in 2010. CST’s website currently lists nine advisers.

The 2010 reorganization established a career ladder and new positions like Advisor I and II, Senior Advisor and Principal Advisor. Ruff’s applications for the latter two were denied. They were potential promotions in both salary and title, the Daily News reported.

According to the Daily News, Ruff’s suit said two people who are Caucasian with “significantly less experience” received the promotions.

One of the people promoted was an adviser for only four months, and the other previously served as an enrollment and retention coordinator.

A request for comment from Ruff was pending.

Additionally, Ruff’s suit quoted from a paper penned by an administrator who denied him the promotions. He presented the quotation as “evidence of [Temple’s] discriminatory intent.” Matthew Campbell, then-director of CST’s Office of Student Services, wrote the paper for his doctoral program.

According to the suit, Campbell wrote “I sense that I am always limited by my identity as a white, middle-class male of protestant background. . . . I’m still suspect of my own intentions, aware of my subconscious desire for self-preservation/promotion and the [white] privilege granted to me unwittingly.”

Campbell now serves as Vice President for Learning and Student Success at Pierce College in Puyallup, Washington. A request for comment was pending.

Ruff wrote in the suit that he obtained a “notice of right to sue” from the federal government’s Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. He filed the suit in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.

Temple spokesman Ray Betzner said in a statement: “Mr. Ruff, who continues to be employed at Temple, bases his complaint on claims that are roughly four years old. The EEOC has already reviewed his case and closed it after finding no evidence of any violation of law.”

            Joe Brandt can be reached at jbrandt@temple.edu or on Twitter @JBrandt_TU.

Police looking for suspects involved in robbery at 18th and Jefferson streets

The Philadelphia police are looking for suspects connected to a robbery of a 23-year-old female on the 1500 block of 18th street near Jefferson.

The incident happened on July 27 where a surveillance video released by police shows a woman attempting to get into her home when she was approached by three males. The suspects punched her in the face multiple times and attempted to take her iPhone but fled toward Cecil B. Moore Avenue when they were unable to.

The first suspect is between 18-21, 5’5”-5’8”, of thin build, has dread locks as well as neck and arm tattoos. The second suspect is between 18-21, between 5’5”-5’8”, of thin build and has a “Caesar haircut.” The third is between 18-21 and wore a blue Nike shirt.

The female was taken to Temple University Hospital.

Anyone with tips or information is asked to call 215-686-8477.

Theobald’s salary far below other presidents’, study says

By Paul Klein

President Theobald's makes more than $100,000 less than the median public university president's salary. | TTN FILE PHOTO

President Theobald’s makes more than $100,000 less than the median public university president. | TTN FILE PHOTO

President Theobald has a salary well below many other public university leaders, ranking No. 173 among all public college executives, according to a Chronicle of Higher Education survey published earlier this summer.

With total compensation at $352,021 in the 2013 fiscal year, Theobald made nearly $127,000 less than the middle of the pack. However, in the current fiscal year, Theobald will receive a significant bump in salary.

Slated to earn $450,000 this fiscal year and an additional $200,000 in deferred compensation as part of his contract, Theobald would move up 67 spots in the rankings, assuming no other salaries change.

A university spokesman said Theobald is also provided with a residence for personal and university use with an additional car and driver for university business.

The Chronicle’s survey, published May 16, ranked the salaries of 255 chief executives at 227 public universities or systems nationwide. In Pennsylvania, Theobald’s compensation was also below average.

University of Pittsburgh’s outgoing chancellor, Mark Nordenberg, made nearly $300,000 more than Theobald and was ranked the 43rd highest. Nordenberg, who will retire Aug. 1, served Pittsburgh for more than 36 years, 19 of which he was chancellor.

The second highest Pennsylvania public university president was Pennsylvania State University’s Rodney Erickson who received $618,220 and was ranked 42nd. Erickson, who retired last month, assumed the position in late 2011 after president Graham Spanier was ousted in the heat of the Jerry Sandusky sex abuse scandal.

With the exception of head executives who served for less than a whole fiscal year, like Temple’s former interim president Richard Englert, Theobald’s compensation only trumped Michael Driscoll of Indiana University of Pennsylvania. Theobald earned nearly $25,000 more than Driscoll.

Not one active Pennsylvania state college executive was in the Top 10 or even the Top 20. However, next fiscal year will be a different story for Pennsylvania’s state higher education leaders.

Pittsburgh’s new chancellor Patrick Gallagher will be receiving a base salary of $525,000. Penn State’s new president Eric Barron will make $800,000 with $200,000 in transitional payment.

Paul Klein can be reached at tua80386@temple.edu.

Shooting close to campus tests new CSS communications policy

By Sarai Flores

The scene of the shooting, 2036 N. Carlisle St.,which left two men in the hospital.

The scene of the shooting, 2036 N. Carlisle St.,which left two men in the hospital. | SARAI FLORES TTN

Philadelphia police responded to a shooting outside an apartment building less than a block off Main Campus Tuesday evening, which left two non-Temple-affiliated males in the hospital.

A 22-year-old male was found lying in the foyer of an apartment at 2036 N. Carlisle St. with a gunshot wound to his chest and was taken to Temple University Hospital in critical condition. Temple police said the man was visiting from New York.

A police spokesperson said that while officers were at the scene, they noticed a male driving away in a van. After briefly pursuing the vehicle, police reported that it crashed into a wall on North College Ave., near Girard College. The 19-year-old male driver was transported to Hahnemann University Hospital with injuries related to the incident.

The 19-year-old male’s involvement in the shooting is still being investigated and he had not been formally charged as of Wednesday night.

According to police, the 22-year-old male was in critical condition as of Wednesday and had yet to be questioned. No charges have been made to anyone involved in the shooting and police said they believe there were several males involved in the shooting.

Although the incident occurred around 9:38 p.m., Temple students were issued a TU Alert at 11 p.m. that night.

“The problem was we had a problem with our computer dispatching system,” said Charlie Leone, executive director of campus safety services.“It went down and so we didn’t get the information right away but Philly [police] was there very fast.”

The shooting came four months after a March 21 incident just off Main Campus where a female student was attacked and hit in the face with a brick by a group of teenage girls. Many students criticized the university for not immediately notifying them of the incident.

University officials initially said the incident wasn’t reported because it was off-campus, therefore not in their jurisdiction, and they weren’t notified about it by Philadelphia police until hours after. Leone said Tuesday’s incident showed a reformed communication policy since the attacks in March.

“Talking with the student population… they wanted more information. So we saw something like this and we wanted to make sure we had put the information out so they know what happened,” Leone said. “We’re trying to do better and we’re trying to improve.”

However, Inella Ray, a senior economics major, believes Temple police still have room to improve with communicating.

“I guess I come from a biased point of view because I grew up in the inner city, but I don’t rely on Temple police for safety,” Ray said. “I don’t think Temple police do a good enough of a job. We end up finding out about stuff very late. They need to do a better job communicating.”

Temple police have stated that they are continuing to heavily patrol the area.

Sarai Flores can be reached at sarai.abisag.flores@temple.edu or on Twitter @saraiaflores.

Brian Williams to receive SMC award this fall

By Joe Brandt

Brian Williams, a 12-time Emmy-winner, will speak at the SMC awards ceremony this fall. | Photo courtesy of Justin Stephens, NBC

Brian Williams, a 12-time Emmy-winner, will speak at the SMC awards ceremony this fall. | Photo courtesy of Justin Stephens, NBC

NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams and six alumni will receive honors from the School of Media and Communication this fall, SMC announced Monday.

Williams, who has anchored NBC’s national news program since 2004, will receive the Lew Klein Excellence in the Media Award on Sept. 26. Additionally, six SMC alumni will be inducted into the school’s Hall of Fame.

Among these alumni are musician John Oates, of the duo Hall and Oates, and Tracy Davidson, a reporter and anchor from Philadelphia’s NBC 10.

Williams, a 12-time Emmy-winner, will speak to attendees at a special luncheon held in Mitten Hall.

Proceeds from the luncheon will fund approximately 24 SMC scholarships, according to the school’s press release.  Tickets for the reception and luncheon are currently $150 per person.

Past recipients of the Excellence in the Media Award include CNN’s Anderson Cooper, former “The View” co-host Whoopi Goldberg, Today Show host Matt Lauer and Robin Roberts of Good Morning America.

Oates commuted to Temple in the late 1960s and graduated with a bachelor’s degree in journalism in 1970. Oates and his musical partner, Daryl Hall, recorded songs in the WRTI studio, back when the station was student-run.

Davidson joined NBC 10 in 1996 as a morning anchor and received a graduate degree from SMC in 2006.

The other Hall of Fame inductees will be Gerhart “Jerry” Klein, chairman of the Broadcast Pioneers of Philadelphia, Larry Margasak, formerly of the Associated Press’ Washington bureau, Claire Smith, news editor at ESPN, and Meredith Avakian-Hardaway, director of communications and marketing at the Philadelphia Bar Association.

Joe Brandt can be reached at jbrandt@temple.edu or on Twitter @JBrandt_TU.

Oversight by pilots a possible cause of Katz plane crash

By Joe Brandt

Pilot error may have contributed to the plane crash that killed Temple trustee Lewis Katz and six others while taking off from an airfield near Boston on the night of May 31, according to a federal report.

The National Transportation Safety Board, a federal entity that investigates transportation accidents, released a preliminary report of the incident on its website Friday, June 13.

The Gulfstream IV was equipped with a gust-control system that could lock certain plane components in place such as the tail flaps, known as elevators, and the wing flaps, called ailerons. The system is intended to protect these parts from potentially damaging wind gusts while the plane is parked, according to the report. The report stated that winds were calm during takeoff.

NTSB analysis of the cockpit’s flight data recorder showed that the pilots performed no control check before the flight, and that “elevator control surface position during the taxi and takeoff was consistent with its position if the gust lock was engaged,” the report read.

Investigation of the cockpit showed that the gust lock switch was found in the “off” position and that a separate latch to gust lock the tail flaps was off as well.

The plane, which was co-owned through a limited liability company and had logged nearly 5,000 hours of flight, never took off and instead went off the end of the runway and crashed through lighting and an antenna before landing in a gulley and erupting in flames.

According to the report, tire marks that indicate braking started 1,300 feet, or nearly 400 meters, from the end of the runway. According to a flight data recorder, numerous braking mechanisms were activated and the plane was going 100 knots, or roughly 115 miles per hour.

The NTSB added that the report is preliminary and subject to change.

The three passengers—Susan K. Asbell, 68, Marcella Dalsey, 59, and Anne Leeds, 74—were all friends of Katz. The crew on-board included pilot James McDowell, 51, copilot Bauke “Mike” de Vries, 45, and flight attendant Teresa Ann Bernhoff, 48 had all worked for Katz for at least 10 years.

Katz was honored in a memorial service held June 4 at Temple’s Performing Arts Center, with speakers including former President Bill Clinton, Governor Corbett, trustee and comedian Bill Cosby and Katz’s family.

Joe Brandt can be reached at jbrandt@temple.edu or on Twitter @JBrandt_TU.

AxisPhilly to be disbanded

By Marcus McCarthy

Temple’s Center for Public Interest Journalism announced Friday that its nonprofit news website AxisPhilly will cease operations, and a new project will be started in its place.

Started in 2012, AxisPhilly was intended to cover local civic issues but, according to a press release on the organization’s website, “did not achieve consistent local impact and fell short of serving as a collaborative hub for the emerging news ecosystem, both of which were goals at founding.”

Run through the university’s School of Media and Communication, the CPIJ, which oversaw AxisPhilly, will change its focus to a startup by former Digital First Media and WashingtonPost.com executive Jim Brady. The news startup will be called Brother.ly, according to Technical.ly Philly.

Brady’s startup will seek to “hit younger audiences that may not be using traditional journalism resources,” Temple’s journalism department chair Andrew Mendelson told        philly.com.

As well as starting Brother.ly, Brady will teach a course in entrepreneurial journalism at Temple. OpenDataPhilly, the city’s official open data portal that was run by AxisPhilly, will be managed by the CPIJ.

AxisPhilly last year received a national online journalism award for general excellence. The website, which had four full-time employees who will receive severance, was created with funding from a $2.4 million grant by the William Penn Foundation. With lacking readership and dwindling funds, the project needed work, something SMC Dean David Boardman said was not worth pursuing.

“The burn rate was such that this was going to come to an end one way or another unless we could find new funding,” Boardman told Philly.com. “It was our judgment that finding funding for this…was not where we wanted to put our energy.”

Operation of AxisPhilly will cease June 13.

Marcus McCarthy can be reached at marcus.mccarthy@temple.edu or on Twitter @marcusmccarthy6.

Lewis Katz memorial to be held Wednesday

By Patricia Madej

Temple will hold a memorial service for Lewis Katz, alumnus and former trustee member, Wednesday, June 4, at 11 a.m. at the Performing Arts Center. The service will be open to all.

Katz, 72, died Saturday evening when the private Gulfstream IV he was on erupted into flames. Katz was traveling from Massachusetts to New Jersey with seven others members aboard. There were no survivors.

In addition to being a board member, Katz was an avid donor to the university. In November, he donated $25 million to the school, the largest in the university’s history. The Temple Medical School will be named after Katz in his honor.

Katz was also a co-owner of the Inquirer, Daily News and Philly.com after winning a bid to buy the trio along with other media subsidies for $88 million last week along with trustee H.F. “Gerry” Lenfest.

Katz received his bachelor’s degree in biology from Temple in 1963.

Temple student assaulted off Main Campus, Police say

By Marcus McCarthy

Police released a surveillance video of five men they said assaulted a Temple student just off Main Campus on the 1800 block of Berks Street around 11:50 p.m. on May 5.

In the video, the Philadelphia police said that a 20-year-old male who was a student at the university was walking through an alley when he was approached from behind by five unknown males. The student was struck on the back of the head by two of the unknown men then beat up once on the ground, the police said. The men proceeded to take the student’s cellphone.

The student was taken to Temple University Hospital where he was treated for a dislocated right shoulder, scrapes and a bloody nose.

The footage in the video, taken by a security camera on the corner of Berks and 18th streets, shows five men walking south on 18th Street.

Anyone with information are asked to call the Philadelphia police at 215-686-8477.

Marcus McCarthy can be reached at marcus.mccarthy@temple.edu or on Twitter @marcusmccarthy6.